top of page

How to Pick the Right Tenants for Your Rental Property

Choosing the right tenants is one of the most critical decisions a landlord can make. A reliable tenant can ensure steady rental income and property care, while a poor choice can lead to costly repairs, legal battles, and missed rent. Here's a guide on how to find the best tenants for your property.


1. Screen Applications Thoroughly


Start by creating a detailed rental application. Look for applicants with stable income, positive rental history, and good credit. Red flags include frequent job changes, past evictions, or significant gaps in their rental history.


2. Perform Credit and Background Checks


A credit check will show you how responsible the potential tenant is with their finances. This is important as it’s a reflection of their ability to pay rent on time. A background check can reveal any criminal history, helping to ensure the safety of your property and other tenants.

3. Verify Income and Employment

It's recommended to rent to tenants whose monthly income is at least three times the rent. Ask for pay stubs or employer confirmation letters to verify this. It's also helpful to check their employment stability, as long-term employment usually correlates with long-term tenancy.


4. Contact Previous Landlords


Talking to previous landlords can provide valuable insight into a tenant’s history. Ask about their payment habits, how well they took care of the property, and whether the landlord would rent to them again.


5. Meet the Tenants


Meeting your potential tenants in person (or virtually) can give you a feel for their personality and whether they'll be a good fit. People often reveal more in casual conversation than on paper.


6. Consider Their Rental History


A tenant with a strong, stable rental history is more likely to be reliable. Watch for red flags like short stays at multiple locations or disputes with previous landlords.


7. Set Clear Rules and Expectations


Before signing a lease, ensure that all terms and expectations are clearly outlined and agreed upon. This includes policies on pets, rent due dates, and property maintenance. Setting these clear boundaries will help ensure that there are no misunderstandings down the line.


8. Use a Property Manager to Protect Your Investment


If tenant screening feels overwhelming, working with a property management company can ease the burden. At Calmora Properties, we specialize in finding reliable tenants who will respect your property and pay rent on time. Our comprehensive tenant screening services include credit checks, rental history verification, and background checks, helping you lower the risk of problem tenants.


A property manager not only assists in selecting tenants but also helps with the ongoing management of the rental, including rent collection, maintenance, and legal issues. This can significantly reduce the stress involved in property management and help safeguard your investment for the long term.


Conclusion


Choosing the right tenants is crucial to ensuring your rental property remains a good investment. By conducting thorough screenings and partnering with a trusted property manager, you can minimize risks and enjoy the benefits of passive income without the headaches. For expert help managing your property, contact Calmora Properties today.

 
 

Want Us to Manage Your Property?

Utilizing a Property Management Company is the safest and easiest way to manage your property. To get started, Book a Call with Calmora or learn more at our Rental Property Management Page.
Headshot.png
Daniel Nielsen
Residential Rental Property Specialist
bottom of page